Comments on Lost Addicts Blog: LOST: Season 3 Episode 18 - D.O.C.

but definitely not a bad theory that it could be a...

2007-05-02T14:49:00.000-04:00

but definitely not a bad theory that it could be a photocopy of DESMOND's photo. If that's the case we may find out more in Ben's Flashback next week with all of the DHARMA stuff!

lol #1 fan eh? Thanks for giving me a bigger ego!...

2007-05-02T14:47:00.000-04:00

lol #1 fan eh? Thanks for giving me a bigger ego!

Anyway....I thought the same thing about the Photos. The producers, however, confirmed in a podcast that there are, in fact, 2 copies of the photo. I agree we only saw ONE taken during the Desmond Time-Travel flashback. But if you remember, end of season 2 when Penny picks up the phone...she has the same picture framed on her

Naomi wasn't lying and it wasn't a coverup. The i...

2007-05-02T14:13:00.000-04:00

Naomi wasn't lying and it wasn't a coverup. The island is actually caught in a time warp and Naomi traveled back in time to arrive on the island before the wreckage was discovered w/ all the dead people.

Or, don't forget that Desmond's photo was actually only 1 of 1 prints they got that day. So where did the 2nd copy come from? It was a color photocopy that Desmond's old hatch mate

To Anonymous above: thanks for the correction. ...

2007-04-30T08:46:00.000-04:00

To Anonymous above: thanks for the correction. Watched episode again. Jin said "not Korean, Chinese" so yes, Naomi was speaking Chinese he could NOT understand.

As for Season 4, it probably won't be coming on until January so that we can have a straight run of all of the episodes with no breaks in between. I'm all for it!

Updates from latest Producers' Podcast:

I think that Eye-Patch man was pretending to be de...

2007-04-29T18:17:00.000-04:00

I think that Eye-Patch man was pretending to be dead to get away. He's weird anyway!

Liked this episode - GREAT write-up Mike!

BTW when it ends in May - when is it back?

hmmm...i'm not sure if that timeline is accurate e...

2007-04-27T10:06:00.000-04:00

hmmm...i'm not sure if that timeline is accurate either. First of all...I'm not sure why they put the conception at EXACTLY 8 weeks when Juliet said "ABOUT" 8 weeks and then specified 53 days. This definitely makes it DAY 37 of 90 days. After My ridiculous math mistake, I busted out my calculator on that one! lol

But from that timeline...it doesn't look like the raft launched

Mike,

Here's a pretty cool time line not su...

2007-04-26T23:24:00.000-04:00

Mike,

Here's a pretty cool time line not sure if it's accurate but they put the conception at day 33 when Palo and Nikki are off diving for diamonds: (they assume the ultrasound is day 88) I forget maybe Juliet said the crash was "about" 90 days ago?

http://tviv.org/Lost/Timeline_1

i thought about possibly Klugh still being alive. ...

2007-04-26T13:07:00.000-04:00

i thought about possibly Klugh still being alive. Only thing that I keep coming back to is...the producers always said once someone is DEAD they are DEAD. i.e. Jack's dad is dead, ethan is dead, Boone is dead, shannon is dead, ana lucia is dead.

There was always speculation that Mikhail didn't die. They kinda just left him there didn't they? I think they still need to explain it

Just a guess, but I think Jin might have learned h...

2007-04-26T12:52:00.000-04:00

Just a guess, but I think Jin might have learned his martial arts skills in the Korean military.

And if Mikhail is alive, does anyone think that any of the other Others might have resurrected as well? Like Ms. Klugh?

Dude, this is Lost, who says it has to make sense!...

2007-04-26T12:28:00.000-04:00

Dude, this is Lost, who says it has to make sense!! :p

I love reading into Lost too much! :p I think maybe that is what we have done here, Sun says it's Jin's so we have to go with her until proven otherwise - she would know if she has been with someone else on the island and considering she didn't specify whether this other lucky swine was on or off the island it is possible...
But

I listened to the podcast too. Sounds like it was...

2007-04-26T12:04:00.000-04:00

I listened to the podcast too. Sounds like it was just them joking around again lol.

I'm thinking maybe Michael and the Raft crew were gone for about 10 or 11 days before Day 48 happened.

If you remember in season 1...Sun tried to poison Jin and keep him from getting on the raft (she poisoned Michael instead).....anyway..long story short...Jin and Sun make up after a long

In the podcast prior to this episode, dated 20/04/...

2007-04-26T11:45:00.000-04:00

In the podcast prior to this episode, dated 20/04/07 Damon and Carlton suggested there was a 3rd 'suspect' for fatherhood of Sun's baby - whether this was just a joke(never can tell with them two) who knows - if your maths is right, Mike - is it possible that someone else is the father? Maybe I wasn't paying too much attention but did Sun specify that the other guy she slept with was OFF the

Do you know she was definitely speaking Chinese? ...

2007-04-26T09:55:00.000-04:00

Do you know she was definitely speaking Chinese? I thought Jin was correcting Desmond for assuming it was Chinese?

Also...my bad on the DAY count...you can skip that entire bullet point. 90-53 = 37 lol. OOPS! But even so....weren't the two of them fighting at the time...prior to the raft launch? Something is fishy!

Not sure if it matters, but Jin actually couldn't ...

2007-04-26T09:47:00.000-04:00

Not sure if it matters, but Jin actually couldn't understand Naomi b/c he said she was speaking Chinese, not Korean.